Peer Review by clos (United States)

Below, you'll see any text that was highlighted with comments from the reviewer.

Tap on comment to view. Using a mouse?

Hover over comments to view. On a touch device?

6.- El Flaco (Nine Abadón)

By: MarSan


He hasn't been home for a long time. And if he has, he's been drunk. Either way, the lights haven't been on for months and the letters by his doorstep only keep on coming. Everyone pretends not to know who sends them, for the sake of the remitter, but it has just as well turned into one of the street's traditions, to check if they're still there each morning. Elena, nosy as she was born, has stolen some of them and sometimes lets the other girls at the café read them. Only sometimes. Today, they're sprawled all over the table and designed in tremulous handwriting. 

Ay, mi Flaco, 

The house isn't as bright without you around. I've never been much of a writer, you know this. But when you're gone I tend to fall into melancholy. How's your job? Hurry up and finish it so I can tell you everything that has happened over here. The girl on the floor below, the one with the sad eyes, I'm sure she's up to something. The Morales and the Smiths sometimes come over with fresh cookies. And Elenita, well you know how she is, she's kept me well informed. Please respond as soon as you can.

With all the love in my heart, Mom. 


Flaquito mío, 

A tragedy happened, so now I'm staying with the young teacher, Sophia. I can't even write it down, dear. Please come visit, I'll tell you about it. If you can't come, respond as soon as you can. 

Love you always, Mom.


Ay Flaco, 

What have you done? 

Love, Mom

Mi Flaco, mi corazón, 

I didn't want to believe the rumours. I still don't. I'm old, you know I can't take much more. I told you over and over that fighting and stealing would get you nowhere. You told me it was a job, Flaco. What you did can't be that, because it's not work. Why don't you listen to me? I can help, why don't you believe me? I would say I don't want to see you anymore, but not seeing your face once again would kill me quicker than my age is. Please. Come home. 

Love you, Mom.


Today, they're disorganized and stained. Today, some tears fell on top of the last lines. It's been three years since the Fire, and only three hours since the old widow that lived with Sophia passed away. Elena and the girls are silent, smoking. Cruz is picking out flowers for the funeral, nothing but sweet peas and daisies. By the time Eustaquio arrived, the woman's breathing matched that of the rhythm of her rocking chair. The wind howled and sobbed, as it would for the next week. 

Some days later, Claudia Bernal would be buried next to the small chapel. Some neighbours would be there, maybe the Smiths and Morales. There'd be no family members of hers. And her tombstone would carry no name, no dates. The young teacher Sophia would cry silently, stay there hours after everyone left. 

Some months later, Sophia would receive some money in the mail. It'd have a note, For the troubles and the funeral. Thank you, El Flaco, attached next to it. 

Some years later, flowers of different colors would adorn the nameless tomb. 

Peer Review

I really liked the story of this piece. It's sadness and plot pulled me and gripped me till the end. Especially with the letter structure and how that plays into that story, that's really creative! I also like all the details sprinkled in about the characters and the location and how that plays into the story. This piece really surprised me and kept me wanting more with all the details and story points. Nice!

I feel like there are a lot of places you can expand on and a lot of details you can use. For example, you can try elaborating more on the relationship between El Flaco and the mother in the past through one of the letters. Also I think describing more on where the setting takes place and how that can affect the story can make it more effective in detail. Also, I'm really interested in hearing more about El Flaco and his backstory, what he's been through and a possible change that occured in his life. This could be mentally and physically too. Also I don't know if this could work, but you can try exploring a different letter addressed to EL Flaco, perhaps from a different character. Also you can try and incorporate an almost torn up letter from El Flaco, indicating that he could've tried to write a letter back but couldn't do so. I think those could be fun concepts to explore. Great job!

Reviewer Comments

I really liked this story and what it was about. The story of El Flaco and his mother as unfortunate events keep on occurring. You do a great job revealing great details, exploring that, and referencing that later on. Really makes the story interconnected, grabbing your attention. Also I really like your grammar usage and how you manipulate the spanish language into the story. I feel like you could expand a lot if you were to flesh it out and explore more details if you wanted to. Really good job with the piece!