Josh was Noel's neighbor and they had been friends before they could talk. They told each other everything, so it makes sense that she would fall for him. She first realized she had feelings for him when he started dating her best friend, Ava. When they broke up Noel was confused, 'hadn't they been happy? they seemed happy.' She asked Josh why they broke up and he said it was mutual, but when she asked Ava she said it was because it was obvious that he had feelings for someone else, but he had her blessing to date 'the other girl' Noel was so confused. When she got home she talked to Josh again. She asked him why he lied to her, he said he would never lie to her. She took a leap of faith and asked who the other girl was, before he could answer she told him she was falling for him. He stared at her for a second in shock then he said, she was the other girl and he was falling for her too.